More Than a “Give” Jar: A Family Giving Night That Lets Your Child Choose the Cause

For parents of children in Grades 3–5 — a quarterly family ritual

Most families with a money jar have a “give” jar. Every few dollars your child earns, a coin or two drops into the jar marked Give, and one day the jar gets emptied into a donation box somewhere. It is a good habit — but it is not really a decision. Your child never chose the cause, never looked into what the money does, and never saw the difference it made.

A family giving night changes that. Four times a year, your family sits down together, and your child is in charge: they research two causes, compare them, and decide where the family’s giving money goes. Giving stops being the third jar and becomes a skill — the skill of choosing well, and of giving more than money.

Here is how to run one.

1. Pick a night and a pot

Choose a regular night — the first Friday of each season works well, and it is easy to remember. Put it on the calendar like any other family event. The ritual matters as much as the money: the same night, the same table, the same job to do.

Set aside a fixed amount for each giving night. Twenty dollars a quarter is a good starting point, or five dollars a month if that fits your budget better. Put the cash in an envelope and write “Giving Night” on it. The money is real, the amount is yours to choose, and your child can see exactly what they are deciding about.

2. Let your child pick two causes to research

This is the heart of the night. Beforehand, ask your child to find two causes that help people or animals in or around Whitby. You can start with categories they already care about: a food bank that helps local families, an animal shelter, a program that gives children school supplies, or a charity that plants trees in the community.

Then research them together. Visit each cause’s website and answer three questions: What does it do? Who does it help? What would our money buy? A food bank might say that ten dollars fills a hamper for a family of four. A shelter might say that twenty dollars feeds a dog for a week. Write the answers down — your child is building a case, and a good case needs facts.

3. Compare them side by side

On giving night, lay the two causes out next to each other on a sheet of paper. Make a simple chart together:

  • Who does it help?
  • What does $10 do?
  • What does $20 do?
  • What do we like most about it?

Then let your child present their case for each one, as if they were making a pitch. Which cause would help the most people? Which one feels closest to home? Which one would they be proudest to tell a friend about?

There is no wrong answer here. The point is not to pick the “best” charity — it is to practise weighing two good options and choosing with reasons, not just feelings. That is a money skill most adults never learn.

4. Decide together — and give more than money

When your child has made their case, decide as a family where the envelope goes. Let your child be the one to make the donation, whether that means dropping the money off, donating online with you beside them, or mailing a cheque. The act of handing it over is the moment the decision becomes real.

Then ask a second question: what else can we give besides money? A charity needs time and skills too. Your child could help sort food donations, draw cards for seniors, or join a neighbourhood cleanup. An afternoon of helping often teaches more about giving than a twenty-dollar donation ever could — and it costs nothing at all.

5. Follow up and see the difference

Giving that disappears into a website is easy to forget. So follow up. If the cause sends a thank-you note, read it together. If there is a photo or a short report about what donations achieved, stick it on the fridge next to the chart from the night.

Then mark the next giving night on the calendar, and let your child know they are in charge again next time. Four nights a year, and by the time your child is ten, they will have researched eight causes, made four real decisions, and learned that giving is not something you do with spare change — it is something you do on purpose.

Final Thoughts

A “give” jar teaches a child to set money aside. A giving night teaches them to choose. That choice — researching, comparing, deciding, and then seeing the result — is the real lesson, and it is one they will carry into every other money decision they make.

Start small: one night, one envelope, two causes. The rest will grow from there.


Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, tax, or health advice. For personalized guidance, consider speaking with a certified financial advisor.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *